Topics
- US Jewish opinion on Israel and Zionism698 figures: 609 verified, 23 computed, 66 qualified
- Jewish opinion on Israel and Zionism outside the US432 figures: 348 verified, 13 computed, 71 qualified
- Israeli public opinion199 figures: 157 verified, 4 computed, 38 qualified
- Views of Israel and of religious minorities among non-Jewish publics558 figures: 511 verified, 27 computed, 20 qualified
- Discrimination against Roma and Muslims177 figures: 133 verified, 19 computed, 25 qualified
- Global religious demographics and development560 figures: 376 verified, 182 computed, 2 qualified
- Income and education by religious group1,120 figures: 889 verified, 121 computed, 110 qualified
- Jewish representation in elite achievement and wealth46 figures: 19 verified, 25 computed, 2 qualified
- Holocaust restitution, and compensation for other historical atrocities39 figures: 13 verified, 6 computed, 20 qualified
- Antisemitism policy, campus cases and settlements35 figures: 22 verified, 1 computed, 12 qualified
- Diaspora support for Israel101 figures: 78 verified, 0 computed, 23 qualified
How each figure was checked
- Every number in the text and in his charts and tables was extracted, one record per figure or chart cell.
- Each was checked against the source he cited: the page itself, its charts, its data files, or an archived copy when the live page was gone or blocked.
- A second, more careful pass re-checked every figure that was not plainly verified, plus a random 10% of the verified ones (all 307 sampled held).
- Large data tables (Pew religious composition, World Bank GNI, UNDP HDI) were checked by script against the edition current when he wrote.
- Wikipedia and sources that only pass on someone else's figures never count on their own: the figure is published only when the original source confirms it.
What is published
Figures the source states (verified), figures that follow exactly from what it states (computed), and figures where the source supports a narrower form, shown in the source's own words (qualified). Everything else is listed as not confirmed, with the reason:
- Source differs (96) The source gives a different value or contradicts the claim.
- Not found in the source (301) The source was read but does not contain or support the figure.
- Secondary source only (329) The cited source relays the figure from elsewhere (or is Wikipedia), and the original could not be opened online.
- Source unreachable (315) Neither the source nor an archived copy could be read.
- Cites only the author's own posts (84) The only citation is another of the author's own posts.
- No source cited (461) The post gives no source for the figure.
What this is not
“Verified” means the source states the figure, not that the source is right. Each figure is presented as its source presents it; the posts' arguments are in the posts, linked from every figure.